See I don’t really think Elite scratches my space pilot itch very well, and so I don’t really recommend it to people and I don’t think it’s because it’s too complex or challenging - in fact the exact opposite. I found elite dangerous extremely shallow, missing nearly any engaging game loop that I could sink my teeth into. Granted this was 3 years ago but I’ve watched the content updates and they haven’t seemed very large.
I like the flying but the combat seems rather dull with very little progression or optimization capable. Like comparing ED to something like an ARPG or a Dark Souls, there just isn’t good itemization or “character” building last I played.
I liked the trading but there wasn’t a ton going on around the logistics sim to make it really exciting, like flying place to place wasn’t hard and interdictions were rarely challenging and the ship ladder felt kinda small. Mining also felt like the only other thing to do and again, not even a heavily compelling minigame.
They introduced planet side first person shooting stuff and that looked appealing as a new mechanic but it never grew into something that got me to return.
I guess I’m saying to anyone considering it but worried about complexity, give it a go it’s still a fun sim for most people for at least a couple dozen hours. Some people will find hundreds of hours of fun. I personally, and I think a lot of people, will find it lacking though from a space game perspective and there is still a massive hole in the market for a real AAA space sim game to come fill.
To your second point, meaningful progression is locked behind engineering, and a little behind powerplay. Yeah you can get a ship and A rank every module but it won’t hold a candle to a fully engineered build.
But yeah, there are some cool things you can do in the game but the core loop is shallow and grindy as hell. I spent most of my time unlocking engineers, making money, and farming materials to the point where I can get just about anything I want. I feel like cartman in the WoW episode saying “now we can finally play the game” after 1000 hours. Though I did finally join a squadron and that gave me a bunch of stuff to help with. One guy has a carrier and we farmed an assload of minerals and then picked up and turned in a whole bunch of 25m-50m credit mining missions all at once so that was kinda cool.
Oh they also added operations, which are basically multiplayer missions you can join a lobby for, and you don’t actually have to physically be anywhere specific. It’s a huge quality of life upgrade because previously you’d have to actually be in the same system or use telepresence which doesn’t let the telepresence crewmember to use their own ship.
See I don’t really think Elite scratches my space pilot itch very well, and so I don’t really recommend it to people and I don’t think it’s because it’s too complex or challenging - in fact the exact opposite. I found elite dangerous extremely shallow, missing nearly any engaging game loop that I could sink my teeth into. Granted this was 3 years ago but I’ve watched the content updates and they haven’t seemed very large.
I like the flying but the combat seems rather dull with very little progression or optimization capable. Like comparing ED to something like an ARPG or a Dark Souls, there just isn’t good itemization or “character” building last I played.
I liked the trading but there wasn’t a ton going on around the logistics sim to make it really exciting, like flying place to place wasn’t hard and interdictions were rarely challenging and the ship ladder felt kinda small. Mining also felt like the only other thing to do and again, not even a heavily compelling minigame.
They introduced planet side first person shooting stuff and that looked appealing as a new mechanic but it never grew into something that got me to return.
I guess I’m saying to anyone considering it but worried about complexity, give it a go it’s still a fun sim for most people for at least a couple dozen hours. Some people will find hundreds of hours of fun. I personally, and I think a lot of people, will find it lacking though from a space game perspective and there is still a massive hole in the market for a real AAA space sim game to come fill.
To your second point, meaningful progression is locked behind engineering, and a little behind powerplay. Yeah you can get a ship and A rank every module but it won’t hold a candle to a fully engineered build.
But yeah, there are some cool things you can do in the game but the core loop is shallow and grindy as hell. I spent most of my time unlocking engineers, making money, and farming materials to the point where I can get just about anything I want. I feel like cartman in the WoW episode saying “now we can finally play the game” after 1000 hours. Though I did finally join a squadron and that gave me a bunch of stuff to help with. One guy has a carrier and we farmed an assload of minerals and then picked up and turned in a whole bunch of 25m-50m credit mining missions all at once so that was kinda cool.
Oh they also added operations, which are basically multiplayer missions you can join a lobby for, and you don’t actually have to physically be anywhere specific. It’s a huge quality of life upgrade because previously you’d have to actually be in the same system or use telepresence which doesn’t let the telepresence crewmember to use their own ship.