How solid are worker-owned co-ops legally? Can they be written so the co-op can’t be sold off?
According to Wikipedia, Valve has 336 employees. Let’s say Valve becomes a worker-owned co-op. But then let’s say Disney comes along and offers to give every last member of this worker-owned co-op $10 million if the co-op is sold. Can the co-op members vote to sell it, even if say a 2/3 majority is required?
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But with something like Steam, there are shareholders involved beyond just the corporate employees. Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good. The video game market tends towards consolidation, and the general public has an interest in not seeing it enshittified.
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But I would only support switching Steam over now if it could somehow be written into the structure of the co-op that it cannot be sold. I’m fine with a worker-owned Steam running indefinitely. But I’m just as worried about a collective group of people selling out as one billionaire owner.
Let’s say you’re working at Valve. You’re looking at enough money for you and your children to never have to work again. Or look at in terms of time. Let’s say you’re 35 with two kids. Think of what time and attention you’ll be able to shift to your kids without the need to work anymore. Sure, not selling out for the good of a nation’s entertainment may have some noble virtue to it. But at the same time, your kids are only young once. And, for all the pride someone can take at working at a place like Valve, at the end of the day, it’s still a job. Employees still have to go in, do their jobs, answer to the demands of management, meet performance targets, etc. Imagine $10 million, and you can just walk away from all of that forever.
There is nobility in not selling out. But that is still one hell of a sacrifice to ask someone to make, all for the sake of our collective quality entertainment. I would be just as worried as a worker-owned co-op selling out by popular vote as I would a single billionaire selling out. Even if you think you would be the noble one to resist temptation…would your co-workers make the same choice?
Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good.
No, it’s not, and that’s part of the reason why it’s so hard to take people who are mad at Gabe seriously. He got rich off something that is an entirely optional part of life.
In Poland we had a famous bottled water producer coop. “Muszynianka” pretty much the most popular brand, by all accounts a successful business. The workers decided to privatise it.
There is no scenario in which you can guarantee it won’t be sold off for the right price. Even if it were some kind of public utility, the wrong government could still choose to sell it off to the highest bidder. The best you can do is hope that the people who work there understand there’s no going back if they choose to sell and hope no one is willing to let Steam die for a quick pay-off.
complaining that somebody dedicated time to write out a detailed response to you sounds really odd to me. did you just TL:DR? if so that’s cool but you shouldn’t be proud of your lack of effort.
How solid are worker-owned co-ops legally? Can they be written so the co-op can’t be sold off?
According to Wikipedia, Valve has 336 employees. Let’s say Valve becomes a worker-owned co-op. But then let’s say Disney comes along and offers to give every last member of this worker-owned co-op $10 million if the co-op is sold. Can the co-op members vote to sell it, even if say a 2/3 majority is required?
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But with something like Steam, there are shareholders involved beyond just the corporate employees. Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good. The video game market tends towards consolidation, and the general public has an interest in not seeing it enshittified.
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But I would only support switching Steam over now if it could somehow be written into the structure of the co-op that it cannot be sold. I’m fine with a worker-owned Steam running indefinitely. But I’m just as worried about a collective group of people selling out as one billionaire owner.
Let’s say you’re working at Valve. You’re looking at enough money for you and your children to never have to work again. Or look at in terms of time. Let’s say you’re 35 with two kids. Think of what time and attention you’ll be able to shift to your kids without the need to work anymore. Sure, not selling out for the good of a nation’s entertainment may have some noble virtue to it. But at the same time, your kids are only young once. And, for all the pride someone can take at working at a place like Valve, at the end of the day, it’s still a job. Employees still have to go in, do their jobs, answer to the demands of management, meet performance targets, etc. Imagine $10 million, and you can just walk away from all of that forever.
There is nobility in not selling out. But that is still one hell of a sacrifice to ask someone to make, all for the sake of our collective quality entertainment. I would be just as worried as a worker-owned co-op selling out by popular vote as I would a single billionaire selling out. Even if you think you would be the noble one to resist temptation…would your co-workers make the same choice?
No, it’s not, and that’s part of the reason why it’s so hard to take people who are mad at Gabe seriously. He got rich off something that is an entirely optional part of life.
I worked for a company that went employee-owned when the CEO retired. They sold the company to another within a year.
I know most of them are still there five years on, so I guess it worked out for them.
In Poland we had a famous bottled water producer coop. “Muszynianka” pretty much the most popular brand, by all accounts a successful business. The workers decided to privatise it.
There is a possibly better alternative.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_Stiftung
There is no scenario in which you can guarantee it won’t be sold off for the right price. Even if it were some kind of public utility, the wrong government could still choose to sell it off to the highest bidder. The best you can do is hope that the people who work there understand there’s no going back if they choose to sell and hope no one is willing to let Steam die for a quick pay-off.
That’s a hell of a lot of words to reply to a simple comment. LLM much?
Edit: I’m not going to retract what I said, instead I will apologize for what I said. To err is human, and I don’t remember the rest of that bullshit.
Edit 2: I don’t know what that asshole was saying above me but can I get the hell out of this brain? Can I get some help here?
edit; shut the fuck up Clarence or you get the hose again
You think that’s a lot of words?
It is so easy to denigrate others. When was the last time you congratulated, pumped up, or otherwise gave positivity to a person?
Nice. I see what you’re doing you sly dog.
let people effort post.
Ok ok, I get it I just don’t understand why so many words when less words ok.
complaining that somebody dedicated time to write out a detailed response to you sounds really odd to me. did you just TL:DR? if so that’s cool but you shouldn’t be proud of your lack of effort.