Profiting off a service isn’t the same providing said service. Profit is all value extracted after expenses (including personal wages) of providing a service/product.
All profit is extra value charged because “fuck you, I want it”. Profit is theft.
It is not disingenuous to be in opposition to the capitalist system.
Look fuck capitalism and all that, but even in a non-capitalist system some folks will end up “wealthier” than others. They will end up profiting in ways others just can’t by having something others seek. Whether that’s from a highly sought after skill, service or platform. Like even if you drain the entire system of currency, and went back to some form of bartering and/or favor trading, some would just end up with more. Even if you tried to do it top down, black markets would form. My point being that no matter the economic structure we live under, people are greedy. Instead of trying to stomp it out, we should channel and regulate it to better ends which a wealth cap can achieve under the current systems of the world.
Would I prefer a world where that wasn’t the case? Yup. I would honestly prefer a world where socialist values were the norm. And still encourage people to create/join employee-owned businesses where possible, as that’s also something doable that can help make those norms a reality.
However the real issue with your framing is, even if it is true, nobody will really take it seriously. It’s in the same kind of framing as “Taxes are Theft”. Like sure, from a certain point of view. However it really strips all nuance, and makes people recoil instinctively. Not saying you’re wrong, I just believe you can package it better.
And I literally explained the nuance in my comment in plain language. I’m not here to spout paragraphs of political theory. If you want the long winded explanation go read Kropotkin.
There’s a short little book called “The Conquest of Bread” by Peter Kropotkin which explains this in great detail if you want a thoroughly educated and reasoned explanation of the topic.
Profiting off a service isn’t the same providing said service. Profit is all value extracted after expenses (including personal wages) of providing a service/product.
All profit is extra value charged because “fuck you, I want it”. Profit is theft.
It is not disingenuous to be in opposition to the capitalist system.
Look fuck capitalism and all that, but even in a non-capitalist system some folks will end up “wealthier” than others. They will end up profiting in ways others just can’t by having something others seek. Whether that’s from a highly sought after skill, service or platform. Like even if you drain the entire system of currency, and went back to some form of bartering and/or favor trading, some would just end up with more. Even if you tried to do it top down, black markets would form. My point being that no matter the economic structure we live under, people are greedy. Instead of trying to stomp it out, we should channel and regulate it to better ends which a wealth cap can achieve under the current systems of the world.
Would I prefer a world where that wasn’t the case? Yup. I would honestly prefer a world where socialist values were the norm. And still encourage people to create/join employee-owned businesses where possible, as that’s also something doable that can help make those norms a reality.
However the real issue with your framing is, even if it is true, nobody will really take it seriously. It’s in the same kind of framing as “Taxes are Theft”. Like sure, from a certain point of view. However it really strips all nuance, and makes people recoil instinctively. Not saying you’re wrong, I just believe you can package it better.
Man get lost with this capitalist realism shit.
And I literally explained the nuance in my comment in plain language. I’m not here to spout paragraphs of political theory. If you want the long winded explanation go read Kropotkin.
K
one or both sides of every transaction profit, that’s how capitalism works.
Yes and capitalism is the problem. That’s the point.
capitalism is nice, it lets me have cheap industrial machinery from failed buisness
Let’s you privatize the means of production away from the people. I.e. steal what rightfully belongs to the community at large.
and when did said “community” start owning, or lose ownership of any nice industrial robotic arms or other means of production?
There’s a short little book called “The Conquest of Bread” by Peter Kropotkin which explains this in great detail if you want a thoroughly educated and reasoned explanation of the topic.