Last time I checked there were quite a few shenanigans going on with ownership and transfers, seeming very shifty. But since the original Syncthing for Android is abandoned I feel like i have no choice… Has anybody spotted major red flags or was it just a messy maintainer transfer?


I sure as hell hope it will turn out like you say. That said, I need to remind everyone that the guy responsible for the xzutils backdoor did not plant the payload right away. He took months supplying the project with legitimate code before pushing his malicious commit. So “shit has been fine so far” isn’t exactly reassuring; whether the new maintainer can be trusted remains to be seen months, if not years from now. And I won’t be around for that. Trust is a fragile commodity: it’s hard to build, easy to lose, and even harder to regain.
The XZ Utils situation is actually a great example of the 9/10 situations I’m talking about because the attackers boosted drama in in order to socially pressure the developer and break his confidence, which eventually pushed him into ceding control of the project.
That is not what happened here. As anyone can verify in the Syncthing forum thread that started all of this, people were wondering one day why suddenly the old maintainer’s Github was unavailable and why maintenance of the project had quietly switched hands without any communication with the community. This left people justifiably wondering what had happened here: miscommunication during the handover of the project, or something more sinister - a user account compromise + hostile takeover. I’m not saying one is true or the other. But since Syncthing has become a security critical part of my infrastructure, I’ve opted to stay away from researchxxl’s Syncthing-fork for Android. Like I said: trust is a fickle creature.
My point is that the presence of drama is not correlated to the presence of a threat; and often times in FOSS-world (where many devs are volunteers) the drama itself is the actual attack vector.
And my point is that your description of this incident as mere “drama” is inaccurate as it belittles and denigrates the valid concerns brought forward by the community.